Nonunion: causes, diagnosis and treatment of unhealed fractures
Dr. Pili, Orthopaedic Surgeon
Specialist in the treatment of
Nonunions and Osteomyelitis
The treatment of unhealed fractures, which develop into nonunions, and osteomyelitis (bone infections) represents one of the most challenging areas of orthopaedic surgery. Achieving good results requires both appropriate experience and the right treatment methods. Dr Daniele Pili is an expert in the treatment of these complex orthopaedic conditions.
What is a nonunion?
A nonunion is a failure of bone healing that occurs when a fracture does not heal properly within the expected biological timeframe. This condition can cause pain, instability and significant functional impairment of the affected limb.
Causes of failure of bone healing
The causes of nonunion may include high-energy trauma, bone infections, insufficient mechanical stability, poor blood supply, bone loss, smoking, diabetes and previous complex surgical procedures. In short, when a fracture has failed to heal, one or more of these factors may be responsible, often acting together.
Surgical treatment of nonunions
The surgical treatment of nonunions varies according to their location, the presence of infection, bone loss and the patient’s biological condition. Modern techniques can achieve high rates of bone healing even in the most complex cases.
Ilizarov method for complex nonunions
The Ilizarov technique makes it possible to treat complex nonunions using circular external fixation, gradual correction of deformities, bone transport and biological stimulation of bone regeneration.
Bone grafting and external fixation
In many cases, the treatment of nonunions requires the use of biological bone grafts combined with external or internal fixation systems to provide mechanical stability and promote bone healing.
Healing times
Healing times depend on the severity of the nonunion, the presence of infection, bone quality and the surgical technique used. The reconstructive process often requires prolonged clinical and radiographic follow-up.
How is a nonunion treated? Surgical techniques
Today, several techniques are available to treat these complex conditions, each with advantages and disadvantages that should be carefully discussed with the patient during the consultation.
Intramedullary nails
The most commonly used solution for tibial and femoral nonunions without bone loss involves the use of static and dynamic intramedullary nails, with dynamic systems representing one of the most advanced approaches to the treatment of these challenging conditions.
Unfortunately, these more convenient techniques do not always lead to healing. In more complicated cases, different techniques may be used to increase the likelihood of success. Their indications are also more limited than those of more versatile techniques such as external fixation.
Plates and screws
A plate with screws is one of the surgical options for treating nonunion, particularly when high mechanical stability and controlled compression of the nonunion site are required. A plate can stabilise the bone fragments, correct alignment abnormalities and, in certain situations, directly compress the nonunion site to promote healing.
This technique can be particularly useful for metaphyseal nonunions of the radius and ulna and in bone segments where intramedullary nailing is less suitable, or when deformities requiring simultaneous correction are present. In atrophic nonunions or cases with reduced biological healing potential, plate fixation may be combined with an autologous bone graft, generally harvested from the iliac crest or using the RIA technique, with the aim of improving the biological environment at the nonunion site.
The choice between plate fixation, intramedullary nailing and external fixation therefore depends not only on the bone involved, but also on the location of the nonunion, bone quality, the presence of deformity or bone loss and, above all, the possible presence of infection, in which internal fixation is usually contraindicated.
External fixation and Ilizarov bone transport technique
Circular, hybrid and computer-assisted external fixators, combined with other surgical techniques, make it possible to correct large bone defects and severe deformities associated with these conditions. Thanks to these characteristics, they have been used successfully and continue to play a fundamental role in the treatment of these complex conditions.
These techniques are suitable for the treatment of all types of nonunion, whether post-traumatic or congenital. Simple nonunions without significant deformity can be treated effectively with bone grafts, while more severe forms, such as those described in the examples below, require more complex and prolonged treatment.
Can so-called regenerative medicine be used to treat nonunions?
Complex clinical cases
TIBIAL NONUNION AFTER COMPLETE HEALING
Clinical case: treatment of a complex nonunion with deformity and limb shortening.

The images show the case of a young woman with tibial nonunion who underwent surgical treatment after careful assessment of the characteristics of the nonunion and the condition of the limb.
As is often the case in complex situations, the aim of treatment was not simply to achieve bone union, but to restore a stable, correctly aligned and functional limb. The surgical strategy was therefore selected by considering both the mechanical and biological aspects of the nonunion.
The images show the situation before and after treatment. Treatment resulted in healing of the nonunion with an excellent clinical and functional outcome. The patient progressively regained the ability to use the limb normally, eventually achieving a complete return to function and normal daily activities.
This case illustrates a fundamental principle in the treatment of nonunions: there is no single surgical technique that is suitable for every patient. It is necessary to identify the cause of failed healing and assess stability, alignment, bone quality, soft-tissue condition and the possible presence of infection. Based on these factors, the most appropriate reconstructive strategy can then be selected.
In the most complex cases, treatment may require internal or external fixation, bone grafting, deformity correction or reconstruction of bone defects. The ultimate objective remains the same: to achieve bone healing and, above all, restore a functional limb to the patient.
Septic nonunion and bone infections
Septic nonunions are among the most complex conditions encountered in orthopaedic reconstructive surgery. In these cases, failure of bone healing is associated with chronic bone infection and requires a highly specialised multidisciplinary approach.
Clinical case of osteomyelitis of the leg
Although osteomyelitis does not necessarily constitute a nonunion, it is often associated with this condition. The expertise required to treat these two challenging orthopaedic conditions therefore frequently overlaps.
Preoperative photographs and photographs following surgical curettage and local antibiotic treatment
Healing with minimal use of systemic antibiotics
Is humeral nonunion treatable?
Clinical case of humeral nonunion
THIS SERIES OF IMAGES SHOWS COMPLETE HEALING IN A PATIENT WITH HUMERAL NONUNION
To find out more, please feel free to contact me by clicking this link.


















